Scargill 'vindicated' over miners strike – Kevin

South Wales Guardian: Miners clash with police during the strike Miners clash with police during the strike

NEWLY-released Cabinet papers from 1984 justify mineworkers' union leader Arthur Scargill's long-held claim that there was a "secret hit-list" of more than 70 pits marked for closure.

That is the view of Carmarthenshire county council leader Kevin Madge who says this week's disclosure proves the Conservative government headed by Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher "had no credibility whatsoever".

Cllr Madge – a young Cwmaman town councillor at the time of the 1984-85 dispute – admits he remains "very bitter" over the closure of pits in his native Amman Valley.

"The government and the National Coal Board said at the time they wanted to close 20 pits, but these documents show they actually planned to shut 75 mines all along," he said.

"In other words, Thatcher and (NCB chairman) Ian MacGregor were saying one thing in public and something totally different behind closed doors – they were hell-bent on destroying our industry.

"My views on Thatcher and what her policies did to places like the Amman Valley are well known. I make no bones about it – that woman turns my stomach. This valley lost so many pits and so many jobs.

"I'm not saying that all pits were viable and should have been saved, but some – including Betws – certainly could have been kept open for many more years in my view.

"I was never really a Scargill supporter, but what's coming out now proves he was right – and the propaganda against him at the time was huge."

Cllr Madge's views were echoed by former county councillor Hugh Evans, who worked "on and off" as a miner at Betws Colliery over a 20-year period.

"Those plans to close all those pits were something we all knew about, but could never prove," he said. "If we had been able to I think we would have had far more support from other unions.

"Betws Colliery made a big profit every year so of course it could have been kept open – I also believe that what happened to the mineworkers' union had a knock-on effect with other unions."

County councillor Anthony Jones, a former chairman of the South Wales branch of the NUM, said: "All the things we said would happen once the mines were closed, like the rise of gas prices and destruction of communities, have now come back to haunt us.

"The Thatcher government set out to destroy the NUM – it's as simple as that."

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

1:09pm Sat 4 Jan 14

cabinboy2 says...

These papers mark the time when GB changed from a genuine democracy to a sham democracy with its own private army of off-duty policemen ready to accomplish whatever it wished by force.
1300 hundred officers (unidentified) from six counties were said to have had their numbers boosted with military reinforcements and MOD personnel during the shameful demolition of the Peace Convoy in 1985 which cost an estimated £800,000.
These papers mark the time when GB changed from a genuine democracy to a sham democracy with its own private army of off-duty policemen ready to accomplish whatever it wished by force. 1300 hundred officers (unidentified) from six counties were said to have had their numbers boosted with military reinforcements and MOD personnel during the shameful demolition of the Peace Convoy in 1985 which cost an estimated £800,000. cabinboy2
  • Score: 2

8:07pm Sat 4 Jan 14

Magnacastra says...

Amazing that during his tenure Harold Wilson managed to close more mines than the Tories, a little forgotten fact.
Amazing that during his tenure Harold Wilson managed to close more mines than the Tories, a little forgotten fact. Magnacastra
  • Score: -1

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree